Zen Energy Fined $2.15 Million During Liquidation for Energy Efficiency Failures
The liquidators of Zen Energy have encountered a new financial setback as the defunct renewable energy retailer has been slapped with a fine exceeding $2 million due to its failure to fulfil obligations under Victoria’s energy efficiency initiative.
On Wednesday, the Essential Services Commission (ESC) of Victoria announced that Zen Energy would face a penalty of $2.15 million for not meeting its 2025 liability as part of the Victorian Energy Upgrades (VEU) programme. This state-run scheme aims to aid households and businesses in investing in energy efficiency.
Energy Efficiency Certificates and Obligations
Businesses accredited under the VEU generate energy efficiency certificates upon completing eligible upgrades, which can include the installation of air conditioning units or electric water heaters. Each year, energy retailers must acquire and submit these certificates to comply with their efficiency commitments.
The ESC reported that 32 energy retailers successfully met their obligations in 2025, surrendering a total of 7.5 million energy efficiency certificates valued at approximately $591 million, which accounted for 99 per cent of the required certificate submissions across all retailers that year.
“Zen Energy Retail Pty Ltd was the only energy retailer that did not meet its 2025 liability, falling short by 23,965 certificates,” stated the ESC. “Consequently, the commission imposed a penalty of $2.15 million on Zen Energy, which has yet to pay the fine and is currently in liquidation.”
Background of Zen Energy and Its Collapse
Founded in South Australia in 2024, Zen Energy was initially led by Ross Garnaut and later by his son, Anthony. The company had established a significant presence in the renewable energy retail sector, securing major contracts with the state government and other organisations.
In early July, the company plunged into voluntary administration, entrusting the urgent task of guiding the situation to McGrathNicol Restructuring partners Rob Smith and Jason Preston. They were tasked with exploring the best possible outcome for all involved stakeholders.
In an update to creditors in August, McGrathNicol attributed the company’s failure to a high-risk trading strategy that leaned heavily on solar energy while lacking adequate battery storage solutions. They warned that secured creditors might recover only 10 cents on the dollar in the event of liquidation, while unsecured creditors were expected to see no return at all.
Zen Energy’s Assets and Liabilities
In a notable move, Zebre, a joint venture between Taiwan’s HD Renewables and Zen, was successfully divested, with Zen’s stake sold off to investors just prior to the company’s voluntary administration.
The commission’s fine highlights the accumulating issues faced by Zen Energy, including legal actions such as a winding-up order from network provider SA Power Networks over unpaid debts.
As reported by Renew Economy, Zen’s directors noted that the company’s business model exposed it to considerable market risks due to long-term, sizeable positions in the energy market, which had shifted adversely over the past two financial years.
They also cited long, unhedged Large-scale Generation Certificate (LGC) positions alongside paying above the market rate for essential energy products and contracts, which comprised Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs), battery tolling rights, and wholesale agreements.
The administrators further pointed to Zen’s extensive solar generation positions that forced the company to sell electricity at a loss, delays in storage assets becoming operational that could have mitigated short positions during peak evening hours, and possible failures in corporate governance and risk management practices.
This mismanagement led to insufficient risk management regarding the establishment of a long-term business model.
Financial Situation of Zen Energy
As of early August, the administrators revealed that claims from senior noteholders totalled around $177.8 million, with an additional $15 million owed to super senior noteholders. Trade debtors were evaluated at $27 million, while $8 million was owed to staff, alongside up to $347 million in unsecured creditors.
In this context, the relatively small fine from the ESC is likely to be one of the last concerns on a long list of pressing financial issues.
Renew Economy has reached out to the administrators at McGrathNicol for updates regarding the liquidation process of Zen Energy.